The Dark Side of Marketing. How to use the Dark Funnel as a strategy
One of the most frustrating challenges in B2B marketing is watching leads appear in your pipeline with no clear attribution.
You check your analytics, your CRM, your campaign reports but nothing explains where they came from. No last-click source, no UTM parameter, no ad impression. It’s like they just appeared.
Welcome to the dark funnel.
Whilst you’re happy to have these leads, although perhaps struggling to explain to your board, management team etc where these leads are coming from, the fact is, the dark funnel is one of your most powerful strategic marketing tools, if you know how to use it.
In this article, I’ll explore what the dark funnel really is, why it’s not an excuse for poor marketing performance, and how the smartest companies are turning it into their competitive advantage.
What Is the Dark Funnel
The term dark funnel refers to the parts of the buyer’s journey that are invisible to your tracking systems. These are the behaviours, conversations, and influences that shape buying decisions long before someone fills out a form or books a demo.
Examples of dark funnel activity include:
• A prospect hearing your CEO on a podcast
• Someone recommending your tool in a Slack group or private community
• A LinkedIn post that gets seen but not clicked
• Internal buying committee discussions based on past experiences
• A customer sharing your product offline, with a colleague
• Product review sites such as Capterra and G2
None of these show up in your analytics.
They don’t trigger a conversion pixel or get picked up by attribution tools.
But they are genuine activities taken by your prospective audience and they can have a huge impact on whether or not someone engages with you at all and ultimately, buys your product, service or solution.
Why the Dark Funnel is not an excuse
But here’s where many marketers go wrong.
They treat the dark funnel like a black box. ‘We can’t measure it, so we can’t manage it’. Or worse, ‘Let’s ignore it and focus on what we can track’.
This mindset is outdated.
We’ve all heard the stat from Forrester that buyers do 70% of their research online.
Modern buyers are self-educating, peer-driven, and increasingly sceptical of traditional marketing. If your strategy is built only around what’s trackable, you’re missing a huge part of how real buying decisions happen.
Instead of using the dark funnel as an excuse for inconsistent results, high-performing marketers treat it as a strategy to build around.
The question isn’t ‘How do we make the dark funnel go away?‘ It’s ‘How do we intentionally influence this funnel’?
Rethinking your strategy for the Dark Funnel
Accepting that the dark funnel exists is just the beginning. The real opportunity lies in designing a marketing strategy that works in this untrackable space.
Here are just a few thoughts.
1. Invest in trust and value, not just impressions
You don’t need every buyer to click on your Ad. You need them to remember your brand when they’re ready to buy. That means creating content that educates, inspires, and builds trust and value, regardless of whether it’s measurable.
Podcasts, LinkedIn content, speaking engagements, community participation and events are all high-impact, low-visibility activities that influence purchase decisions.
Your goal isn’t to capture every interaction. Your goal is to be present where trust is built.
2. Embrace content that works without attribution
The most effective content in the dark funnel often can’t be tracked:
– A CEO post that gets screenshotted and shared in a group chat
– A customer success story shared in a private Slack channel
– A podcast episode discussed internally by a buying team
You may never know where or when that content had an effect, but it did.
That’s why your content strategy should include ungated, high-value, shareable content designed for consumption, not just conversion.
You want to capture those prospects with high intent, not just those that sit languishing in your traditional funnel as MQLs because they were attracted by a well optimised article but do not have the budget or intent to buy.
Think instead of how people inform themselves.
Behavioural signals such as prospects researching competitors or visits to product review sites.
Their intent and attitude – are they sponsoring events, what are their company priorities, combined with their personal attitudes and interests. And are they ready to buy?
Have they recently got funding? Are their employee numbers increasing?
3. Map Your invisible influence
You can’t measure every step in the dark funnel, but you can build models of how your buyers are likely moving through it:
– What communities are they part of?
– Who do they trust?
– What topics influence their thinking?
Once you understand that, you can start planting the seeds that guide their journey and be where they are, online, even if you can’t trace every path.
How do you measure the impact?
if the dark funnel can’t be tracked, how do you prove its value?
You don’t need perfect attribution. Rather, a mix of leading indicators, blended metrics, and qualitative insights.
Leading indicators:
– Direct traffic (especially home page and pricing pages)
– Branded search volume
– Demo requests with “unknown” sources
These often point to demand being created somewhere you can’t see.
Ask how did you hear about us?
Simple, but highly effective. Add this as an open-text field on your high-intent forms. If you’re worried about making your form overly long, look to see which field you can replace.
Don’t overthink it, just ask the question, and use what you learn.
Look at blended performance:
Track metrics such as:
– Pipeline velocity
– Sales cycle length
– Marketing-sourced pipeline (even loosely defined)
If these are improving, your activities are likely working, even if you can’t pinpoint where.
Turning the Dark Funnel into your advantage
Whilst your competitors are still trying to track every click, they are under-investing in trust-building channels – and creating their dark funnel.
This is your opportunity.
By focusing on the dark funnel:
– You will build brand equity before your buyers ever talk to sales
– You will shorten the sales cycle by influencing decision criteria earlier
– You become the choice when the prospect’s moment of intent finally arrives
The companies winning in B2B today aren’t winning because of better copy – whether Ad copy or organic. They’re winning because they show up consistently in the places buyers trust, even if those places aren’t trackable. Be where your audience is, online.
How companies are owning the Dark Funnel
Let’s take a SaaS company. Instead of just running paid ads and gated eBooks, they:
– Empower their Head of Marketing to post thoughtful content on LinkedIn 3x/week
– Launch a podcast where they interview users and thought leaders
– Sponsor niche newsletters in their ICP’s industry
– Regularly ask new signups how they heard about them and track the responses manually
In their CRM, only 30% of leads have a clear source. But their pipeline triples over 6 months. Why? Because they’ve leaned into visibility and relevance, are building trust, delivering value and not just focusing on conversion mechanics.
The dark funnel is real. It’s not a myth, and as a marketer or if you’re leading the company’s marketing, it’s not something you can afford to ignore.
But it’s also not your downfall.
It’s your competitive advantage if you choose it to be.
– Start designing your strategy to influence your invisible audience
– Trust that building brand, trust, and community works
Your buyers are out there, making decisions before you ever see them.
And remember, Forrester’s Marketing Survey 2024, revealed that 64% of B2B marketing leaders feel that their organisation doesn’t trust measurement for decision-making – anyway.
So what have you got to lose?
